Newswise — Merely a quarter of fresh enterprises endure beyond 15 years, as per information sourced from the U.S. Bureau of Labor and Statistics. Despite fluctuating economic circumstances within and across industries, this figure has remained steady for three decades. A recent analysis published in the Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal proposes a graceful elucidation: the prolonged triumph of a business is heavily contingent on its initial conditions rather than alterations in its markets.
"The impact of environmental shifts on a venture's performance hinges upon its internal procedures," remarks D. Carrington Motley, an entrepreneurship lecturer at Carnegie Mellon University and co-author of the research. "The founding environmental conditions of a business mold these procedures, and they swiftly solidify and become ingrained in the principles governing its operations."
Motley, along with his co-authors Charles E. Eesley from Stanford and Wesley Koo from INSEAD Asia, conducted a comprehensive analysis of over 1,000 ventures established between 1960 and 2011. These ventures spanned across 19 diverse industries, including agriculture, energy, and utilities. To assess the level of dynamism within each industry and during each venture's founding year, the researchers utilized data from the Bureau of Economic Analysis. Additionally, they relied on survey data from alumni to ascertain crucial factors such as the composition of the founding team, the longevity of the business, and its ultimate outcome.
"Ventures established in dynamic environments by a team with functional diversity exhibit a significantly higher capacity to weather market changes," stated Eesley. "However, it does not necessarily imply a greater probability of achieving a favorable exit."
In dynamic environments, businesses often gravitate towards slower, decentralized decision-making processes, emphasizing creativity and flexibility. When coupled with a founding team consisting of individuals with diverse functional roles, these behaviors are further enhanced. Such teams exhibit a broader strategic focus and actively seek out extensive information. These risk-averse structures and strategies contribute to the resilience of businesses in the face of environmental changes. However, the study also discovered that these businesses were less inclined to secure initial public offerings (IPOs) or acquisitions if their respective markets stabilized.
"In stable and predictable environments, adopting a more assertive approach can lead to superior outcomes," explained Woo. "The risk associated with untested assumptions is lower, making the continued use of risk-averse processes less beneficial and potentially hampering a venture's capacity to seize opportunities."
The authors assert that the crucial distinguishing factor for businesses established in dynamic environments by functionally diverse teams was their slower decision-making process. To test this theory, they initially evaluated the performance of such businesses in industries where rapid product development was vital for gaining a competitive edge. Additionally, they examined the speed at which these ventures secured angel or venture capital funding. The findings indicated that businesses founded in dynamic environments by functionally diverse teams fared poorly in both scenarios.
The study suggests that regardless of whether an industry is undergoing significant change or stabilizing, businesses tend to reap the benefits of market changes only if those changes align well with their founding environment. Although the study acknowledges that founding processes can become deeply entrenched, it provides valuable insights to entrepreneurs seeking to navigate both chaotic and calm periods. It highlights the importance of examining the founding structure and internal processes of businesses and consistently reassessing whether they are optimally suited to the market environment in order to enhance their chances of survival and success.
Find a full explanation of the study and how founding conditions affect performance in dynamic environments in the full text, available in the Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal.
RSS